DoS vs DDoS – Difference and Comparison

What is a Denial of Service (DoS) Attack?

A Denial of Service (DoS) attack is a malicious attempt to disrupt the normal functioning of a targeted server, service, or network by overwhelming it with a flood of illegitimate requests. The primary goal of a DoS attack is to render the targeted system inaccessible to legitimate users, thereby causing significant downtime and potentially resulting in financial losses, damage to reputation, and frustration among users. These attacks can target websites, online services, or entire networks, and are carried out by individuals or groups with varying motives, ranging from political activism to cybercrime.

Types of DoS Attacks

DoS attacks can be broadly categorized into several types based on the method used to flood the target system with traffic. Understanding these types is crucial for developing effective defense mechanisms.

1. Volumetric Attacks

Volumetric attacks aim to saturate the bandwidth of the targeted network by sending massive amounts of data traffic. The attacker’s goal is to exhaust the network’s capacity, making it impossible for legitimate traffic to pass through. These attacks are relatively simple to execute and involve the use of botnets—networks of compromised computers—to generate traffic from multiple sources simultaneously.

2. Protocol Attacks

Protocol attacks exploit weaknesses in network protocols to disrupt communications. These attacks involve sending malformed or oversized packets to a target, causing it to become overwhelmed and unable to process legitimate requests. Examples of protocol attacks include the SYN flood attack, which exploits the TCP handshake process, and the Ping of Death, which involves sending oversized ICMP packets.

3. Application Layer Attacks

Application layer attacks target the application layer of the OSI model, where web servers and applications operate. These attacks aim to exhaust the resources of the targeted application, such as CPU or memory, by sending a high volume of requests that appear legitimate. Examples of application layer attacks include HTTP floods and Slowloris attacks, which target web servers by holding connections open for extended periods.

Also Read:   CPM vs eCPM – Difference and Comparison

Motivations Behind DoS Attacks

DoS attacks can be motivated by a variety of factors, and understanding these motivations can help organizations better prepare for and defend against such threats.

Financial Gain

Some attackers use DoS attacks to extort money from businesses by threatening to disrupt their services unless a ransom is paid. This type of attack, known as a ransom DoS (RDoS), is becoming increasingly common as businesses become more reliant on online services.

Political or Ideological Causes

Hacktivists may use DoS attacks to further their political or ideological agendas by targeting organizations or governments they perceive as adversaries. These attacks coincide with significant political events or anniversaries.

Competitive Advantage

Businesses may resort to unethical practices by hiring attackers to launch DoS attacks against competitors, aiming to disrupt their services and gain a competitive edge in the market.

Personal Grievances

Individuals with personal grudges against a particular organization or individual may use DoS attacks as a form of revenge, aiming to cause disruption and harm to their target.

What is DDoS?

Distributed Denial of Service (DDoS) is a malicious attempt to disrupt the normal functioning of a targeted server, service, or network by overwhelming it with a flood of internet traffic. This attack leverages multiple compromised computers and other internet-connected devices as sources of attack traffic, making it challenging to identify and mitigate.

DDoS attacks can cause significant disruption by making websites, online services, or entire networks inaccessible to legitimate users. The primary goal is to exhaust the target’s resources, such as bandwidth, memory, or processing power, so that it can no longer respond to legitimate requests. These attacks can last for minutes, hours, or even days, depending on the attacker’s intent and capabilities.

How DDoS Attacks Work

Botnets and Attack Vectors

DDoS attacks use a network of compromised devices, known as a botnet, to generate a massive amount of traffic directed at the target. These devices, called “zombies,” are infected with malware that allows an attacker to control them remotely. Botnets can include computers, servers, IoT devices, and even smartphones.

Attackers use various vectors to execute a DDoS attack. Some common methods include:

  • Volume-Based Attacks: These attacks attempt to saturate the bandwidth of the target site or network. This includes ICMP floods, UDP floods, and other spoofed-packet floods.
  • Protocol Attacks: These consume actual server resources or intermediate communication equipment, such as firewalls and load balancers. Examples include SYN floods, Ping of Death, and fragmented packet attacks.
  • Application Layer Attacks: These target the top layer of the OSI model, exhausting resources of web application servers. This includes HTTP floods, Slowloris, and DNS query floods.
Also Read:   3G vs 4G – Difference and Comparison

The Role of Amplification

An amplification attack is a type of DDoS attack that exploits the functionality of open DNS servers to overwhelm a target system with DNS response traffic. Attackers send a DNS request with a spoofed IP address (the IP address of the target) to an open DNS server. The server, in turn, responds to the target with a significantly larger DNS response. This method effectively amplifies the amount of data sent to the target, increasing the attack’s intensity.

Common Types of DDoS Attacks

Volume-Based Attacks

  • UDP Flood: This attack sends a large number of UDP packets to random ports on a remote host. The target system checks for applications listening at those ports, and when no application is found, it sends back an ICMP Destination Unreachable packet. This process consumes a large amount of bandwidth, slowing down legitimate traffic.
  • ICMP Flood: Also known as a ping flood, this attack overwhelms the target with ICMP Echo Request (ping) packets, consuming both incoming and outgoing bandwidth and causing the targeted device to respond with ICMP Echo Reply packets.

Protocol Attacks

  • SYN Flood: This attack exploits the TCP handshake process by sending a succession of SYN requests to a target system without acknowledging the corresponding SYN-ACK responses. This leaves the server with half-open connections, consuming server resources and potentially leading to a denial of service.
  • Ping of Death: This involves sending malformed or oversized packets using the ping command, which can crash, destabilize, or freeze a target system.

Application Layer Attacks

  • HTTP Flood: This type of attack involves sending HTTP requests to a target web server at a high rate, consuming server resources and causing the site to slow down or crash.
  • Slowloris: This attack keeps many connections to the target web server open and holds them open as long as possible. It does so by sending partial requests, none of which are completed. This exhausts server resources, preventing legitimate requests from being processed.

Difference Between DoS and DDoS

A DoS (Denial of Service) attack is a malicious attempt to disrupt the normal functioning of a server, service, or network by overwhelming it with a flood of traffic.

In contrast, a DDoS (Distributed Denial of Service) attack is similar but involves multiple computers or devices attacking a target simultaneously, making it harder to defend against.

While DoS attacks originate from a single source, DDoS attacks use a botnet, a network of compromised devices, to amplify the attack’s impact.

Comparison Between DoS and DDoS

Parameter of ComparisonDoS (Denial of Service)DDoS (Distributed Denial of Service)
DefinitionA cyberattack aimed at making a service or network unavailable by overwhelming it with traffic from a single source.A more sophisticated cyberattack that uses multiple compromised systems to flood a target with traffic, making it unavailable.
Attack OriginTypically originates from a single system or source.Originates from multiple systems across various locations.
ComplexityGenerally simpler and easier to execute.More complex due to coordination across numerous systems.
Scale of ImpactLimited to the capacity of a single attacker.Can cause widespread impact due to the sheer volume of traffic.
Detection DifficultyEasier to detect as traffic originates from a single IP address.Harder to detect because traffic comes from multiple IP addresses.
Mitigation TechniquesRelatively easier to mitigate by blocking the attacker’s IP address.Requires more complex solutions like traffic analysis and rate limiting.
Resource RequirementRequires fewer resources to launch.Requires substantial resources to coordinate multiple attacking systems.
Common Tools UsedPing of Death, SYN Flood, HTTP Flood.Botnets, amplification attacks using DNS, NTP, or amplification protocols.
Potential for DamageCan cause temporary disruption but is less damaging.Capable of causing significant and prolonged disruption.
Examples of ImpactTemporary unavailability of a website or service.Major outages affecting businesses, financial loss, and reputational damage.
MotivationOften motivated by personal vendettas or hacktivism.Can be motivated by financial gain, political reasons, or competitive sabotage.
Legal ConsequencesSubject to legal action, but easier to trace back to the attacker.Legal consequences are more complex due to difficulty in tracing all attackers.
EvolutionRelatively static in terms of techniques.Continuously evolving with new methods and strategies.